Video: Crossing the Line: Workplace Harassment — Live AMA | Duration: 1795s | Summary: Crossing the Line: Workplace Harassment — Live AMA | Chapters: Welcome and Introduction (1.4530000000000003s), Defining Harassment (87.203s), Illegal Harassment Defined (250.118s), Handling Complaints Properly (469.95799999999997s), Q&A Session (601.053s), False Complaints Management (821.673s), Workplace Harassment Claims (1078.008s), Edge Cases (1305.173s), Q&A and Closing (1690.758s), Closing Remarks (1733.5729999999999s)
Transcript for "Crossing the Line: Workplace Harassment — Live AMA": Hi. Welcome to today's Mineral Lee AMA Crossing the Line, Workplace Harassment. I'm Sloane Pettyjohn. So when does inappropriate behavior cross the line into harassment, and what should you do when an employee raises a concern? Today, Kara Govro, principal HR and legal analyst at Mitri Tech, will join us to answer your questions about preventing and addressing workplace harassment. Kara helps employers make sense of employment laws and HR trends through clear, accessible writing, webinars, and seminars. Her expertise covers a wide range of workplace issues, including harassment, pay equity, and employee classification. She will do her best to address all the questions submitted in advance along with any additional questions that you have shared in the chat. Just a quick note before we begin, care responses are intended as general guidance and not legal advice for your specific situation. For advice tailored to your organization, please consult an HR expert for... Or your own legal counsel. So MineralLy, Mutri Tech's HR compliance platform provides us this kind of expert HR and compliance support every day. Today, you're getting a live look at that expertise. Whether you're reviewing your policies or working through a sensitive situation, we hope this conversation helps you approach your next steps with greater confidence. So this session runs on your questions. So feel free to also add your questions to the chat right now. And, Kara, let's get into it. Alright. Yeah. Hi, everybody. Let's go ahead and talk harassment because who doesn't love, that conversation? So we're gonna start with a definition of harassment because I find that that is a place where employers and employees get lost. They don't actually fundamentally understand what harassment from the employment law context, means. So we will start there and lay a little foundation. Then we will, of course, get into the questions that you all have submitted ahead of time as well as any you submit right now in the chat. So what's important to know about harassment? Well, not everything is harassment. Employees overuse this word a lot. They love to say things are harassment, that they're being harassed, or that something is a hostile workplace, which is a type of harassment. But just because you are uncomfortable or someone is mean to you or someone is being rude, doesn't mean that harassment is taking place. It doesn't mean that you're in a hostile workplace as far as employment laws are concerned. So there's employment law harassment, and then there's out in the world harassment. And out in the world harassment, when you're saying that your sister is annoying you, she's harassing you, or, you know, the neighbor is harassing you about the leaves that are falling into their yard, that's a different kind of harassment than what we've got when we're talking about employment law. So in employment law, harassment is only happening if there's unwelcome conduct that's based on a protected class or a protected characteristic. So you probably are familiar with these. At the federal level, we're looking at things like race, sex, religion, national origin. These are things, that would... Could lead to a valid harassment complaint. States sometimes have additional protected classes. If you're in a state with those extra classes, you should know about those because they could also lead to a potential harassment complaint. But, basically, you can look to title seven. What's protected in title seven? Those are the categories that we need to be worried about when we're talking about harassment. So if it's not based on one of those protected characteristics, then it's not harassment. It's something else. So what else do you need to know? Well, not everything is illegal harassment. There is, in fact, harassment that is illegal and okay. Maybe not okay, but it wouldn't get you in legal trouble. That said, a lot of potentially legal harassment becomes illegal harassment over time. So there are two ways that harassment can become illegal. One is that putting up with it becomes required for continued employment. So if you've ever complained to HR that the CFO, is being totally inappropriate with all the women on their team, and they said, that's just how he is. Continue to put up with it because we're not gonna deal with it or find a new job. That would be number one. Number two, the conduct is severe or pervasive enough that it creates what we know as a hostile work environment, and that is based on a reasonable person standard. So if you have someone who's just super duper sensitive, you know, at the end of the day, what they report to you might not be illegal harassment, because of their level of sensitivity. That said, pretty much anything anybody is raising that they think is harassment warrants dealing with. So maybe you've got a manager who is mean to everybody or shouts a lot, or uses a lot of profanity. Well, none of those things create a technically legal hostile workplace, a legally hostile workplace, unless the manager is directing their ire at a particular group of people. So if they are incredibly rude to the Christians in your organization, that could be, you know, that could be harassment because it's based on a protected class, and it's unwelcome conduct. So that's that's what we want to be mindful of is that if we do have managers out there who are saying, oh, that's not a big deal. Something that's not a big deal the first time could easily be a very big deal the fifth time and could be a lawsuit the tenth time. So an example I often use here, let's say you've got a particularly religious employee named Robert. He keeps a Bible at his desk, and he prays over his lunch before he eats it. He's not bothering anybody. But you have another employee, named Joe who thinks it's hilarious to call him Bible Bob. So he calls him Bible Bob in the hallways. He says it in the lunchroom. Every once in a while, he'll even say it in a meeting. The first time this happens, it's probably not severe. It's not pervasive because it's only happened once, and you might have a manager say no big deal. But by the time it happens four times, 10 times, or 40 times, depending on how long this goes on, it certainly could become pervasive harassment, unwelcome conduct based on a protected class, which is Robert's religion. So we need managers to understand that even low level bad behavior can be problematic and needs to be dealt with. And even low level bad behavior that isn't harassment because it's not based on protected class is something we probably need to manage if we want to avoid turnover and unhappy employees. So your key things to know should you receive a complaint are that you need to act promptly, like, right away. This this can't be put off for a week or three. I mean, potentially a week. If you really have other major fire grills and it's a a low level complaint, maybe maybe a week is fine. The laws don't stay specifically, but the idea is you need to hop right on these things. You also want somebody doing the investigation who understands these definitions, who can be unbiased, who can be reasonable, you know, preferably someone in HR. We don't generally want our middle managers running, you know, harassment investigations. This is definitely HR work. We wanna document like mad, document like it's your job, doc... Document like it's going to become a lawsuit, and you want to be able to show that you did what was necessary. And then final thought here is close the loop. Make sure the employee who complained to you knows that you took it seriously, you did something about it, and if necessary, the disciplinary action was taken. Alright. So let's go ahead and start with the questions we received. So someone asked... I'll just go to the ones that poured in right now. It can be toxic without being harassment. Yes? Yes. So instead of calling something a hostile workplace, you can call it a toxic workplace. Toxic workplaces are not illegal, though. Employers don't have any legal responsibility to fix a toxic workplace, So that's where knowing the difference is important. You you can blow off a plain old toxic workplace. You can't blow off, a hostile workplace because you've got legal obligations there. Are rude remarks from one staff member to another considered harassment? Like I said, you probably asked that before I said this, but no. Unless the rude remarks are based on a protected class or characteristic, or you think that that is the underlying motivator... Motivating factor. But if you just got two people who are just nasty to each other all the time, that's not harassment. Alright. So let's go to the presubmitted questions here. Someone asked if an employee or former employee decides to sue the company, do you use legal counsel on staff, or do you engage outside legal support? Depends on, first of all, whether you have legal counsel. Most employers probably don't have in house counsel. Most employers in The United States are small employers, small to mid sized employers who who don't have probably a huge HR staff, don't have in house counsel. So most employers are probably going to end up hiring outside counsel, hiring a law firm. You could talk... If you do have internal counsel, you could talk to them about whether they're comfortable defending this claim. But unless they have some experience with employment law, they're probably going to want some outside support. Alright. Here... This was a great one. When should a workplace conflict issue be brought to HR as opposed to the manager addressing it internally? So this will depend on two things. It depends on the type of complaint, how serious it is, and the nature of it, and it depends on the manager. So if you have really competent managers, they're good with people, they're good with handling conflict, they have good emotional intelligence, you know, they're they're bright, then they can probably handle a lot of complaints, a lot of of interpersonal conflicts. And, ideally, that's where we want that to happen if possible. However, there are many industries and environments where your mid level managers are not gonna have any of these skills, and that's okay. In which case, you can still tell people to take these things to their manager. And if the manager is in over their head, they're like, I have no idea how to resolve an interpersonal conflict between these two employees. They can go to HR for support. So HR doesn't necessarily have to take over a 100%. They can help that manager work through it. Or in some cases, they might say, we got this. We understand that this is not your wheelhouse. We'll take care of it. Now that's... What I was talking about just now is with respect to complaints that are not harassment related. So if a complaint is harassment related, my opinion is that it should immediately go to HR. It might get reported to the manager, but that manager should turn around and take it to HR. Leave it in HR's hopefully capable hands, to figure out how to investigate that and manage that. We really don't want to put our faith in in mid level managers who don't fully understand the law, who don't fully understand the scope of liability, that might be there. So take that to HR for sure. How do you handle employees making subtly racist remarks? You shut that down. You bring them in, and you explain to them that those remarks are, in fact, subtly racist. And when they try to argue with you, you say, I don't care about your opinion of these jokes. Other people, perhaps myself included, consider them to be subtly racist. And if you ever say that again, you will find yourself in significant trouble, possibly terminated. So it doesn't matter what the jokester thinks of it. What matters is how it's received. So if you have other people saying, I think that's racist. That feels racist to me. I'm gonna tell you about it. I'm gonna tell my manager. I'm gonna tell HR. That is a problem, and you need to shut it down. Alright. Let's see what we got. A couple of new questions coming in. What is it called when a supervisor tells an employee, nobody likes you, your voice is annoying, and you should look for another job? That's, like, super rude. And you could call it toxic. You can call it mean. You can call it obnoxious. Doesn't really matter what you call it. Those aren't illegal things to say. They're not very nice things to say. If that employee does leave, they're probably gonna be pretty hurt, and it's when employees are hurt that they start thinking about ways to sue their former employer. So I would be having a conversation with that manager about the kinds of things that are appropriate or inappropriate to share with employees, whether they're true or not. Even if nobody does like her and her voice is annoying, you know, there are reasons not to say those things out loud, directly to the individual. So there's a lot of words for that. It's not creating a hostile work environment. It's not illegal. It's just a bad practice. Alright. We've... Okay. This is, we have employees who repeatedly file workplace harassment claims because they don't like someone or someone doesn't like them, but it's not harassment. Anything I can do to stop these frivolous claims? So that was a live question. We also got a question submitted ahead of time. What do you do when a person provides a false complaint? So if you know the complaint was false and made in bad faith, like, you know the thing just didn't happen, they say that somebody grabbed somebody else in the lunchroom, but you've got video footage of the lunchroom and that never happened, then that's when you wanna consider disciplinary action against the person who made a false complaint, a knowingly false complaint. Now if someone misunderstood a situation, we don't want to discipline them for reporting because that could be viewed as retaliation. So if someone reports in good faith and it just turns out that it's not harassment or or it didn't happen, again, they misread a situation, we don't wanna get those folks in trouble. However, if we do have people who are making false complaints on purpose because they don't like somebody, that should be, something you discipline for. Like, that's nonsense. You can't have that in a workplace. It's a big waste of your time. It's them acting like children. So if it's that you've got people comp... Constantly reporting that personality conflicts are harassment, you sit them down and you say, look. This isn't harassment of the illegal variety. This is a personality conflict. You two are gonna have to keep working together. So what can we do to fix this or help this along? And if if it really just comes down to this is a never ending personality conflict, stop telling us about it. You know, maybe eat your feelings in the future. Not everybody is gonna like everybody else in a workplace. That's just how it's gotta be. You suck it up. You work with them anyway. But if they're constantly wasting HR's time or their manager's time with complaints that are definitely false and made in bad faith, that's something you need to find a way to shut down. And, you know, how you go about that is up to you, but it starts by having a conversation with the employee and saying, this isn't harassment. This is a personality conflict, and we can't fix it. You're wasting everybody's time, or maybe we can fix it. How can we help you fix it? Basically, there's managing to do there. Hard managing, unfortunately. Alright. Let's see what else we got here. Oh, alright. This is terrible. A manager slash co owner is taking images from a public chat, but it's... It looks like a work chat of a younger employee and sharing AI altered versions back into the chat multiple times, not explicit, but unauthorized. Does it matter that the subject of the images claims not to be bothered, but it seems to bother other employees? There's been no formal complaint thus far. I would shut that down immediately. Yeah. So it doesn't matter who complains about something if you need to deal with it. If it's harassment, you have an obligation to deal with it either way. Now this, maybe it's not harassment. Age is a protected class. Sex is a protected class. If these two people are of opposite sexes, I like it a lot less. I also just think that's incredibly creepy. So whether it's harassment or not, I think the employer, the HR department, whoever would be well within their rights to say don't do that. You did say that they were maybe a co owner. That always makes it hard. We have a couple presubmitted questions that I've been saving about what to do about bad owners. And I think I would probably point out to this individual that there are potential harassment claims in there, maybe for age, maybe for sex. The fact that they're only doing it to one employee and not a bunch of other employees is a very bad look. So, I mean, that's that's early fodder for a for a harassment claim from that employee. And maybe the employee they're doing to thinks it's funny now or cute now. Maybe they're flirting with one another, but a month from now, that could be an extremely different situation, and that could be the beginning of of the harassment complaint. You know? And this would be pervasive behavior, pervasive unwelcome conduct. Just because it starts as welcome conduct or uncared about conduct doesn't mean it can't turn into unwelcome conduct. And particularly if you think it's making other people uncomfortable, I would attempt to shut that down. And you say they're a co owner, so maybe explain the fact that this could be the early stages of a harassment complaint if that other employee decides that they don't like this, or if other employees who are only witnessing it decide that they don't like it. So, really, it would be in their best interest money wise to stop doing this, before someone decides that they really don't like that behavior. Someone I think was following up to the the false complaints. They they aren't false complaints. It's more like she doesn't say good morning to me, so they file a workplace harassment claim. Yeah. It's not harassment. You need to sit down the employee who's filing these claims and tell them to stop. It's not harassment. It's just somebody behaving in a way that you don't enjoy in the workplace. And if they keep filing complaints and wasting your time, that they're probably gonna be the ones receiving some discipline at the end of the day. So that would be my my approach to that. Again, that's not legal advice for me. I'm not your attorney, but, like, I think there's a lot of nonsense in the workplace, and managers don't like being the bad guy. They don't like being mean. But sometimes you just gotta get in there and tell people that like grown ups or else. A supervisor told an employee that they need to lose weight during a performance review. Is this a type of harassment? No. Weight is not a protected class. However, if that person's weight problem was related to a medical condition, which many people will say and and be true about... Be correct about, then it could be disability discrimination. That's more discrimination than harassment, though, particularly since it's, like, in the context of a performance review. So weight does not immediately trigger, but, again, if it was based on disability, that could be bad. So unless there was a really, really, really, really good reason for the manager to say that, that's the kind of thing that manager needs to be told to never say again. Alright. Okay. What about preferential treatment by managers that's based upon all all the people who are the same race and gender, but if you're not part of the liked group, you won't receive promotions or opportunities. It's not harassment. It's not based on a protected class. They're all the same race. They're all the same gender. They're just not part of the in crowd. Workplaces have clicks. It's true. There are people who get along better than others. There are people who will be deemed outcasts. There are people who are just too weird. You know, whatever the case may be. There... I mean, it sounds like a mean girl situation, and that's really unfortunate, but it's not harassment. So so that's that. Alright. I... I'm gonna go now back to a couple of presubmitted questions, the last few, I think, somewhat related to some questions we had over here. How do you create a positive work environment when the owner of the company causes a toxic situation that causes management to be unable to trust each other. Well, that's really hard. That's gonna be really hard to fix. What I would say is you're probably not gonna have luck with changing the owner of the company or their behavior. So if you can find a way to get the managers to form their own bonds with one another and build that trust between themselves and between departments, It kinda depends on how out in the open the owner's bad behavior is. I mean, if you can have a very diplomatic conversation with your... With the leaders that acknowledges that, like, the owner is not helping us build a team, a cohesive, trustful team here. What can we do to do that on our own? I mean, that's that's ideal if you can make that happen. But if you can't make that happen, then that's just gonna be an unfortunate place to work. It's it's just very true that when the owner is difficult or toxic or whatever, that can be a very a very rough situation for everyone involved, and it's very possible that you're not gonna be able to fix it, that there's nothing that HR or anyone else can do to to fix it other than, you know, find a new job somewhere else with a with a better owner. Somewhat related, how do you convince owners to respect and follow legal requirements if they don't already? Well, if they're not interested in following legal requirements because it's the right thing to do or because it's the law or because, let's say, with respect to harassment, giving people harassment training, if required by law, also makes it less likely that you'll have harassment in the workplace or you'll, you know, have those issues? If none of that works, then you go to the bottom line. Sometimes that is the only thing that an owner or the c suite can hear is, like, dollar bills flapping in the wind. So how much is it going to cost them to not follow the law? It might cost them money in lawsuits. It might cost them money in attorney's fees. Even if something never gets to the lawsuit stage, just trading demand letters back and forth can cost you tens of thousands of dollars. Like, the cheap, cheap attorneys these days are $4.50 an hour. So you're almost certainly gonna be paying, I don't know, $5.06, 800 an hour, if you end up having to respond to even just a demand letter from a disgruntled employee or former employee. So you talk to the owner about the cost of not doing these things, and that could also include, you know, reputation risk and and turnover. You know, if you've got a toxic work environment, harassment or not, if people keep leaving, that's very expensive. So we don't want to be there either. Alright. I'm gonna see if I can take, like, one or two more questions here. Someone said how much are... How much of these harassment complaints are taken care of by HR versus legal counsel? So like I mentioned before, a lot of employments... Sorry. A lot of employers don't have in house counsel, and HR is not really gonna know what's going on. I mean, they'll they'll understand the basis of it, but if a lawsuit has come in or a demand letter has come in, probably the attorney you hire is going to take care care of most of it. However, they're going to ask for a lot of information from HR. They're gonna need a lot of documents. They're probably gonna have to have a lot of conversations. But, you know, HR is not gonna be sitting at the counsel table in court, with with the attorneys. So it it kinda depends on on what stage you're at and how sappy your HR people are, but chances are the attorneys, if you've hired them, are going to do the heavy lifting. Hi, Sloan. Alright. Alright. Let's see if we've got one more question in here. Someone said... I think this was just in response to me saying managers sometimes don't like to manage. They said, I have a manager that trembles every time he needs to meet with an employee, and I get that. I I do. And so there... There's probably some training to be had there, but he's doing it. Sounds like he's doing it. So maybe over time, he'll improve. We just need to remember that it's hard in the moment, but, generally, having these conversations, stopping problems early will will lead to better outcomes. Alright. I will go ahead and stop there. Just a few seconds ahead of time. Awesome. Thank you, Cara, for helping us navigate questions about workplace harassment and just responding to complaints and just handling these investigations. And thank you to everyone who joined us and shared a lot of questions today. We host a new conversation each month as part of the Mineral Elite Live AMA series. Our next session will focus on ACA reporting and takes place on December 15. The registration link is in the chat, so be sure to save your spot. And then before you go, just please take a moment to complete that exit pool, and we appreciate you joining us today and hope to see you at the next one. Thank you, everyone.